Skip to main content

Book Review: Cinder by Marissa Meyer

I have recently become quite interested in the idea of modern fairy tales. That is, modern retellings of classic fairy tales, meant to be marketed to tween/teenage readers. It is fascinating to me that the crux of these tales stands the test of time and needs only to be updated for a modern audience. I believe that these adaptations are paving the way for a new breed of feminist, and that contrary to what some people may think, the heroines of these classic stories are actually excellent role models for strong young women. More on that to come.

To that end, I recently finish reading Cinder by Marissa Meyer, the first in a quartet called The Lunar Chronicles.  It is, in a word, stellar. And it fits the mold of what I described above perfectly. Clearly this is a retelling of Cinderella, and in fact Meyer places quotes from the original story at strategic breaks throughout the book. But in this case, we are not in 18th century Europe, but Asia of the future. The book is set in a place called the Eastern Commonwealth, part of a united global community that is not only plagued by threats of war from the government on the moon, but from an actual plague itself. Oh, and Cinderella (Linh Cinder) is a cyborg.

With all this going on, Cinder becomes much more than a story about the good girl triumphing over her evil stepsisters--in fact, one of Cinder's stepsisters is actually a wonderful person. It becomes instead a book about hope, about social status, about racism, bigotry, and diplomacy. As Cinder finds herself more and more embroiled in the politics between Earthens (Earth people) and Lunars (Moon people), she has to confront difficult choices between self and country, single and whole.

Add to that Cinder's complete antithesis from the usual heroine: she is part girl part robot who works as a mechanic fixing cars and androids. She prizes practicality, compassion, and intelligence, and she recognizes the importance of her place in the world while simultaneously working toward a better future for herself and her race in the face of personal tragedy.  A noble role model indeed.

Style-wise the book was generic. At least, it was no more complicated or lyrical than you would expect from a young adult novel geared toward girls in their early teens. This is not to say that the writing was not good. In fact, I found myself enjoying the writing with the same enthusiasm that I enjoyed The Hunger Games. I even found myself reading the book in first person, though it was written in third person. Older readers might find the writing a little simplistic, but not clumsy or immature. Just when things started to go flat for me, Meyer slipped in something funny or sarcastic that made me smile and reengage (case in point, the robotic foot that is left behind at the ball in place of a glass slipper).  Ultimately, any lack of style in the writing is saved by the sheer amount of captivating material in the characters and plot. This novel is a prize in what is becoming an increasingly popular genre, taking a real classic and remaking it into something relevant, thought provoking, and engrossing for any reader of young adult fiction.

Bring on the sequels! And potentially a movie deal.

Comments

  1. Thanks for reviewing this book! I saw it at B&N the other day but was afraid to pick it up in case it was a shallow and redundant reinterpretation of the old fairytale. You've given me hope that it's worth checking out.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Winner, Winner, Chicken Dinner(s)!

Did you know that you can buy an entire chicken at the grocery story for less than $6? Well, you can. And if you are willing to put up with a little home butchering, it can make enough food to last you almost a week. I bought a chicken last weekend for our Sunday meal, and used the last of it just yesterday. This is a huge help when you are trying to mitigate the expensive cost of meat in your grocery budget. First, it needs a little work. I roasted the chicken for our weekend dinner, and I always butterfly it because it cooks faster that way. I'm not going to sugarcoat it--butterflying a chicken is kind of gross. Really gross, actually. But if you can overcome your squeamishness, it cooks great. There are a lot of great tutorials for doing this on YouTube, but here is how I did it.  Step 1: Remove the giblets (the heart, neck, and gizzard). This is disgusting because you must reach into a dead animal and pull out its organs. But once they are out, you can throw them away, ...

I Am Afraid of Snakes

I am giving you some valuable information here. Snakes are my biggest fear. My second biggest fear is that upon discovering my biggest fear, people will pounce on it and send me snakes in the mail, or put them in my bed, or my car, or throw them in my face like David Bowie did to Jennifer Connelly in Labyrinth . So, the other day, when Norris was getting ready to go on a short trip, we were talking about all the critters in our yard. Normally I like all these critters. We have a bunch of toads (like, seriously, we have like 20 toads in our back yard—and that’s just the ones we can find. Toads freaking love us.) and a couple tree frogs, and some praying mantises, and snails, and a family of birds (dusky flycatchers—the babies all just flew away and I was very sad) that nested in our patio light fixture, and for a few days we had a raccoon living in one of our trees. We also have a couple of hawks (I mean two hawks that are in a committed relationship. We know they care about each...

The Fungus Among Us

Aren't they pretty?  I love mushrooms. I think they are cute, and pretty, and fascinating. Before all this rain, I even bought a couple ceramic mushrooms to put in the flower bed because they make me think of the forest floor in a fairytale. Now that we’ve gotten so much moisture, though, we have tons of living mushrooms all over the garden! The main garden. Carrots in front. Speaking of the garden itself, it is nice and green, but having a little trouble actually growing because all the weather has kept temperatures cooler than they normally are this time of year. We haven’t gotten nearly as many spring blooms as we normally do, and all the tropical plants, like our passion flower vine and hibiscus and bird of paradise are enjoying the rain but not the cooler temps. Yellow squash!  Nevertheless, here is what is happening in the garden this year so far: carrots, onions, garlic, tomatoes, purple bell peppers, sweet jalapenos, zuchinni, land yellow sq...